I.A Decision Taken For Him
InterviewerYour grandfather was in the Indian Civil Service, your uncle was killed at the Irrawaddy in 1944, and your father commanded the Army. What was it like growing up — was service ever presented to you as a choice?
OfficerI hardly remember my grandfather Sir Gurunath Bewoor1. I was born in Jan 1945 and he died in Nov 1950. I cannot recall his face. My uncle Maj MG Bewoor, a Rimcollian, was killed in Burma in Feb 19442 before I was born. Growing up and attending local schools run by officers’ wives was how we were educated in Delhi. All schools were Convent types and others were run by Christian Brothers. Most of us Fauji kids attended morning school in the homes of defence officers where most wives were teachers. There was no formal presentation made with suggestion to become a Fauji for me. By the time I had reached 10 yrs, Jan 1955, I sat for the RIMC exam, went for the interview in Mumbai and by about Sep 1955 was told that in Jan 1956 you are joining father’s school in Dehra Dun. There was no formal indoctrination or grooming for the Armed Forces. I suppose it was a decision taken for me by my parents.
InterviewerYou entered RIMC in January 1956 and left in May 1961 as Cadet Captain. What did that appointment actually involve at sixteen, and what did it teach you that you were still using at forty?
OfficerI was quite unaware in late 1960 that I would become Cadet Captain in Jan 1961. It makes you wonder what you have become, the senior most cadet in school. To command the parades, conduct Roll Call every evening, give report at PT & Drill classes. Say the Grace before and after all meals. To supervise evening Rounds at the Lawn where Cadet NCOs conducted the punishment, so to speak. To be aware that misconduct by any cadet is to be found out, investigated, and punishment awarded. No one can hit or abuse another cadet, esp a junior. No cheating and no theft. First termers to be taken care of by their immediate seniors and oriented into school rules, customs, duties etc. Along with Section Cdrs and NCOs we talked about these matters in the Senior Ante Room. If there was a bad boy he was warned and punished, and only if there was no change would we take up the matter with Section Masters. Indeed, I used all of it at the age of 40 yrs and earlier. As a sqn pilot, as a flying instructor, as an Air Force Examiner and finally when I was a Commanding Officer, followed by being the Senior Instr at Staff College Wellington3.
Contextual Notes and Historical References
- 1 · Sir Gurunath Bewoor
- Sir Gurunath Venkatesh Bewoor of the Indian Civil Service, Director General of Posts and Telegraphs from 1934 to 1941.
- 2 · The Irrawaddy, 1944
- His uncle, Madhav Bewoor, trained at Sandhurst, was killed in action in Burma in February 1944 during the Fourteenth Army’s campaign. He was the elder brother whose path to the Rashtriya Indian Military College their father followed.
- 3 · Staff College, Wellington
- The Defence Services Staff College at Wellington in the Nilgiris, where mid-career officers of all three services are trained together.
II.Two Sons, and a General
InterviewerYou joined the Air Force, and so did your brother — while your father was an Army general. How did he take it?
OfficerMy father never once dissuaded me from selecting Air Force as First choice in the application form for NDA. During the 3 yrs at NDA not once did he try to suggest that I look at Army as the better option and how it would help me in my career. I am certain that our father rather enjoyed and was proud that his sons were pilots in the IAF. In the year 1985, it so happened that we both were flying the very latest aircraft on the IAF inventory. Keshav1 was flying the Mirage 2000 in Gwalior and I was flying the IL-76 at Agra. The IL-76 would be flying Support for Mirage ferries from France to India via Athens to Cairo to Doha and into Jamnagar. On one such ferry both Keshav and I were together, he flew the Mirage and I flew the IL-76.
InterviewerYour father was Chief of Army Staff from 1973 to 1975 and you were a serving officer throughout. What is it like to be a junior officer in one service while your father runs another? Did you ever feel you had to prove yourself independently of him?
OfficerThere was never any pressure for me to prove my capabilities because my father was COAS2. That kind of stress was never there and my father ensured that he never let me feel his overbearing presence. I was also very much aware that my COs never felt that the son of COAS was serving as junior officer. Both Keshav and I performed without any external help from the COAS. We both earned our Flying Instructors badges; we both were awarded the ‘A’ Category Instructor Rating. We both commanded IAF squadrons. We both earned our Vayu Sena medals3 in our turn, I in 1990, Keshav in 1995. We both became instructors at DSSC. None of it was out of turn and none of it was done with the pressure of having to prove our worth to our parents. They knew what we were and how were performing.
Contextual Notes and Historical References
- 1 · Keshav Bewoor
- His brother, Air Vice Marshal Keshav Bewoor of the Indian Air Force.
- 2 · COAS
- Chief of Army Staff. General G.G. Bewoor held the appointment from 16 January 1973 to 31 May 1975, succeeding Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw. He had been commissioned in 1937, won the Sword of Honour at the Indian Military Academy, fought the Japanese in Burma with the 5th Baluch, and commanded Southern Command during the 1971 war.
- 3 · Vayu Sena Medal
- An Indian military decoration awarded for distinguished service of an exceptional order in the Air Force.
III.Eleven Types
InterviewerAllahabad, Jodhpur, and then Dakotas at Begumpet. What do you remember of the Dakota, and what is it like to be handed an aeroplane of that vintage as a young man?
OfficerOur trainer aircraft were solid aeroplanes. The basic trainer HT-2 was made by HAL; the Harvard IV was of World War II vintage as was the Dakota1. There was never any doubt that these aircraft were unsafe or not airworthy. The Dak was so reliable flying on Single Engine that we were constantly shutting one engine for practice and often landing with only One Engine working.
InterviewerEleven types and around five thousand hours. Is there one aircraft you would fly again tomorrow if someone let you, and one you were glad to see the back of?
OfficerThere are two aircraft that I got rather attached to. First was the AN-122 on which I logged 2000 hrs. A wonderful kite. The second is the IL-763, a powerful machine that revolutionised Indian Air Force airlift capacity and philosophy. I trained in USSR on the IL-76, and flew many special and critical missions in it, incl the airborne assault into Maldives. These two aircraft I would love to fly again. There is no aircraft that troubled me enough to see the back of it.
Contextual Notes and Historical References
- 1 · The Dakota
- The Douglas C-47, military version of the DC-3, and the workhorse transport of the Second World War. The Indian Air Force flew Dakotas into the 1980s; one carried the first troops into Srinagar in October 1947.
- 2 · The An-12
- A Soviet four-engined turboprop transport, inducted by the Indian Air Force in 1961 and flown for three decades, including in support of operations in Ladakh.
- 3 · The Il-76
- The Ilyushin Il-76, a four-engined heavy-lift jet transport inducted from 1985, known in Indian service as the Gajraj. It roughly trebled what the Air Force could move in a single lift.
IV.Jaffna, and the Friday Courier
InterviewerYou flew with the IPKF in Sri Lanka. Not the politics of it — what was it like to fly those missions, and what has stayed with you?
OfficerFlying support of IPKF1 was in some way routine and different also. Flying in troops & rations was normal, but inducting the T-72 tanks2 was very critical. Jaffna RW was short, the surface was rough with loose gravel. Wheel braking was not very good, so the pilot must touch-down very close to the beginning of the RW and use Reverse & Full Brakes, to stop comfortably. Sometimes, off loading the T-72 tank could take as much as three hours. Tragic also. We flew in Gurkha troop on Day One, and next day brought back many bodies after their battles with the LTTE3. The IL-76 also started flying a weekly Air Courier service from Delhi to Chennai and back on Fridays so that forces coming out of Lanka could get to North India quickly. Many from the North East would board the Assam Courier on Saturdays to get home within two days of leaving Sri Lanka. It was the joy on the faces of these men of the Indian Army that has stayed as a pleasant memory.
Contextual Notes and Historical References
- 1 · The IPKF
- The Indian Peace Keeping Force, deployed to Sri Lanka from 1987 to 1990 under the Indo-Sri Lanka Accord, and drawn into sustained fighting with the LTTE in the north.
- 2 · T-72s by air
- Moving a forty-one-tonne main battle tank by air is at the outer limit of what a transport aircraft can do, and the loading and unloading is slower and more dangerous than the flying.
- 3 · The LTTE
- The Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam, the armed movement that fought for a separate Tamil state in Sri Lanka from 1976 until its defeat in 2009.
V.Operation Cactus
InterviewerYou have written the sequence of Operation Cactus, so I won’t ask you to repeat it. What I want to know is the hour before take-off. You had scanty intelligence, possible SAMs, and four hundred men about to get aboard your aircraft. What was going through your mind at Agra?
OfficerThe team from Delhi briefed us at about 1600 hrs on 03 Nov 1988. Having decided to attempt a direct landing our complete focus was on how to get there the fastest, the length of the RW, any Navigation aids that we can use. But most important was keeping the mission secret from Civil Aviation authorities at Delhi, Nagpur, Hyderabad, Bangaluru and TVM1. We planned to tell the Civil air traffic control that only one IL-76 was flying from Agra to TVM on a routine mission. In truth we would launch two IL-76s. The briefing and orders I gave was that we have to do this job and preparations & planning must be flawless. For the very first time India was intervening militarily, during peace conditions, into a foreign country whose elected government had sought help. There was no declaration of any hostilities. Neighbouring nations and the super powers were not to be kept in the information loop. These and such thoughts were exercising my mind and those of my colleagues.
InterviewerYou flew the approach on two amber lights against a black sea, and the lights went out as the tyres touched. Can you take me through those last thirty seconds as a pilot would experience them?
OfficerThere were no Amber lights as such to guide me. On 03 Nov 88 at about 2135 hrs we contacted the Hulule2 air traffic control, ATC. The RW lights were switched on for about 10 seconds when I aligned the IL-76 with the RW and the lights went off. The whole ground environment was pitch black; Moon rise was at 0130 hrs on 04 Nov 88, Last Quarter, no use at all. Diwali, Amavasya3 was on 09 Nov 1988. Normally when a pilot comes to land at night the surrounding city lights are on, traffic shows moving lights, and there is a very distinct difference between the lights on the ground and the stars in the sky. Over Maldives, there were no lights on the Ocean, there were no lights of traffic on the island of Male, nor on the RW island Hulule. The Hulule island was dark. Such a situation can cause confusion to pilots. The Navigator had a very large Echo of Hulule island on the Ground Mapping Radar. He was guiding me to keep in the Centre of that Echo, by saying Left Left; Right Right. Not the smartest way to make an approach to land. I had to keep the Nose of the IL-76 pointed at the very beginning of the RW as I could remember it for those 10 seconds. I had told the Flight Engineer to be prepared to Open Full power without hesitation in case we were not going to land in the beginning of the RW. The IL-76 engines are very powerful. In my mind I knew that I must deliver the troops who I have flown close to 3500 Kms across India. This landing was the pivot around which the izzat4 of 44 Sqn, the IAF and India was fixed. I had to get it right the first time, there would not be a second chance.
InterviewerYour father was still alive. He died a little under a year later. Did he know what you had done? What did he say to you about it?
OfficerMy father did know about the landing and had read various media reports. I am unaware of how the TV channels covered the story; those days I hardly watched TV. Besides, I was in Agra, he was in Pune we would not meet again. My parents had visited Agra in early 1988, and I would not see my father alive after that visit.
Contextual Notes and Historical References
- 1 · TVM
- Thiruvananthapuram, the southernmost major airfield on the Indian mainland and the natural staging point for a flight to the Maldives.
- 2 · Hulule
- Hulhule, the island airport serving Malé, separated from the capital by water. Taking it intact was the condition of everything that followed.
- 3 · Amavasya
- The new moon. He notes it to explain the darkness: moonrise came hours after the landing, and the moon was in its last quarter.
- 4 · Izzat
- Honour, standing, the regard in which one is held — in military usage, the collective reputation of a unit, which an individual holds in trust.
- · On the question
- The interviewer’s question assumed two amber lights. His correction is kept in place, and the question with it, because the record of what he was asked is part of the record of what he said.
VI.Baghdad, and Ivanovo
InterviewerWhat was it like to teach flying in another country’s air force, in another language and another culture? What did you have to change about how you instructed?
OfficerIn Iraq, method of instruction is English. Their pilots get trained at British civilian flying schools as civilians, and then join the Iraqi Air Force. Teaching flying was very normal and easy. The IAF had been sending flying instructors to Iraq since about 1960 in batches for two years deputation. The pupil pilots were fully familiar with standard terms of aviation in English.
InterviewerIs there anything from those two years, it may be a place, a person, an incident, that has stayed with you?
OfficerThe Iraqis are a very cultured people with a very long history and civilisation that flourished at the same time as did Indian civilisations. What many could not fathom was what Hindus were. More than one officer wanted to know that if I was not a Christian, nor a Jew neither a Muslim; then what kind of person was I? There were many officers who had been trained in IAF training units, and they were able to clarify. Iraqis suffered far too much during the six year war with Iran from 1980 to 19861.
InterviewerYou were also sent to the Soviet Union to train on the Il-76. What do you remember of being an Indian officer inside the Soviet system?
OfficerWe were not controlled by the Soviet system as people imagine it to be. The Russians are very fond of Indians and India. Indian Air Force is the only Force that has flown Russian aircraft and defeated western aircraft of Pakistan in two wars. Everywhere else in the world, western aircraft have prevailed over Russian aircraft. We had full freedom to move about in the city of Ivanova2 located about 300 Kms North East of Moscow, where our training academy was. We enjoyed many Ballets shows in that city and also in Moscow. What was remarkable was that inside the Russian campus was small forest and a lake. In July when we arrived it was green and very beautiful. As winter came and December 1984 descended, the lake as frozen, everything became white with snow, temperatures dropped to Minus 25 centigrade. The change was too much to comprehend for our Tropical ways of seeing nature from season to season.
Contextual Notes and Historical References
- 1 · The Iran–Iraq War
- Fought from September 1980 to August 1988. He gives it as six years; it ran for close to eight, and his deputation fell within it.
- 2 · Ivanovo
- A city north-east of Moscow, site of a Soviet military transport aviation training centre where Indian Air Force crews converted onto the Il-76.
VII.Twenty-Two Years in a Software Company
InterviewerYou spent twenty-two years at Onward Technologies, longer than many people’s entire careers. What did the Air Force give you that worked in a software company, and was there anything that you had to unlearn completely?
OfficerAt Onward Technologies, what I found was that there flowed a lot of compassion in their functioning. The CMD Mr H Mehta, the GM Mr A Chafalkar, the Admin Managers, the Technical Managers had huge amounts of patience. Their aim was to sell their products and services, but there was a method and system in their functioning. It was quite easy for me merge with Onward and its ways. I had a lot of responsibilities placed on me, and the senior management reposed full faith in my being able to get the job done well and on time. The value system, dedication, keeping the aim in focus, sticking to schedules, working with full discipline and no diversionary tactics was well appreciated by Onward and allowed me to work freely without interference from anyone. I also learnt how non-military organisations work, and how their style and speed of working cannot be compared with Indian Armed Forces. One important lesson is that a Fauji should never use the phrase, “--- in the Air Force it was like this”. Never keep quoting from your service life, the more silent you are, the more inquisitive the civilian engineers are, and you should tell your stories only when asked for. Do not impose your long years of military life on civilian workforce. The corporate world does not and cannot function like the Armed Forces, and should not be expected to and made to. Then it will cease to be a business house.
InterviewerYou write for Salute, and for a policy foundation now. What made you start writing, and what are you trying to get down that would otherwise be lost?
OfficerI always had a flair for writing and public speaking, both go hand in hand. I did a lot of debating at school. At NDA I won the Bhavani Shankar Memorial Debate contest one term. During my service I wrote for our Safety Journal, and in my units I was often tasked by the CO to write the service paper on different subjects for sending to higher formations. So, after retiring, I continued and send my articles to many journals, and Digital Portals on both military and other subjects. The article for Salute was only done once. Yes, there are many topics that I feel need to be widely circulated and comments solicited because they are critical for our Services and India too. If such stories are not written, the matter will be lost and will disappear into oblivion.
InterviewerYou describe your life as having been fairly ordinary, with “lots of satisfaction and contentment and very few regrets.” Looking back now, what gives you the greatest sense of fulfilment?
OfficerI am convinced that my 28 yrs with the IAF have been very normal and ordinary. There have been no spectacular events and shining successes that can be boasted about. The landing at Hulule was unique and I think I have received due recognition and reward for it. The fulfilment comes because I lived my service life without any blemish to me, my family or my unit. I know I gave my best, and that the IAF valued what I did, and told me about it. Fulfilment also comes from the long-standing friends that I still have, from the endearing messages I get from my friends, juniors and seniors too. That someone has the time to write to you or call you or ask you for to share a meal together, is proof of consummation of a life well lived. The superior contribution of my wife, Vinita, in this fulfilment cannot be overstated and I am grateful for that help.